📱 Text “INSIDER” to 1-888-459-8182 for urgent benefits updates & resources

A free Benefits Insider guide · Plan year 2027

10 Medicare Mistakes to Avoid for 2027

The mistakes that cost people money every Open Enrollment, why 2027 makes each one more expensive, and the one move that avoids it. Verified November 1, 2026.

2027
Start here. Your plan mailed an Annual Notice of Change by September 30. Every mistake on these two pages starts with not reading it. If you do nothing by December 7, you are enrolled in the 2027 version of your plan on January 1, whatever it now costs and whoever is now in its network. Renewing is not choosing.
1

Mistake: Assuming your plan is still there next year

KFF counts 4.3 million people whose private Medicare plan ends on December 31, 2026: about 3.1 million in Medicare Advantage plans and 1.2 million in stand-alone drug plans, including plans leaving their county. For 2027, 193 counties have no general-enrollment Advantage plan with drug coverage at all, up from 123; about 638,000 people live in them. Molina and Clear Spring Health left the market entirely.

AVOID IT: Find your notice and read the first paragraph. If your plan is ending, choose a new one between October 15 and December 7 so nothing lapses on January 1. Every plan still approved for your county is in your report.

KFF, "More than 4 million Medicare beneficiaries will have their Medicare Advantage or stand-alone prescription drug plan terminated at the end of 2026," October 27, 2026; KFF, plan availability by county, 2027.

2

Mistake: Treating "do nothing" as the safe choice

There are two different letters. Non-renewal: your plan is ending; ignore it and you are moved to Original Medicare on January 1 with no drug coverage and no yearly cap on what you can be billed. Consolidation: your insurer merged your plan into a different one; you are moved automatically, nothing feels wrong, but your doctors, drug tiers and costs may all have changed, and CMS does not give you the extra enrollment window for it.

AVOID IT: "Terminating" or "non-renewing" is Letter A: you must choose, and you get a Special Enrollment Period from December 8 through the last day of February. "Will be combined with" or a new plan name is Letter B: October 15 to December 7 is your only clean window.

CMS enrollment and disenrollment guidance: plan consolidations are not terminations; Medicare.gov, Special Enrollment Periods.

3

Mistake: Shopping by the premium

About 69% of general-enrollment Advantage plans for 2027 charge a $0 premium, so the premium tells you almost nothing. The number that decides a bad year is the yearly in-network out-of-pocket maximum, and among those $0 plans it runs from $199 to $9,850. The median is $6,650. Two plans with the same $0 on the front can be $5,000 apart in a year with a hospital stay.

AVOID IT: Read a plan in this order: network type, out-of-pocket maximum, drug coverage and deductible, premium last. Your report sorts by out-of-pocket maximum for that reason.

Benefits Insider analysis of the CMS CY2027 Landscape file (October 18, 2026 revision), 3,553 general-enrollment MA and MA-PD plan segments.

4

Mistake: Not making the two phone calls

Network problems are the second most common reason people leave an Advantage plan, behind cost, in NerdWallet's analysis of five years of CMS disenrollment surveys. A plan can add or drop doctors during the year, and the plan's directory and the doctor's front desk do not always agree. The hospital you would actually use matters as much as your primary doctor.

AVOID IT: Call the doctor's office: "Are you in network for this plan in 2027?" Then call the plan and ask the same question. Do it for your hospital too. Each plan's provider directory is linked on its page in your report.

NerdWallet analysis of CMS Medicare Advantage disenrollment reasons surveys, October 2026.

5

Mistake: Assuming your prescriptions are still covered the same way

Drug lists and tiers are reset every year. A drug can move to a higher tier, gain a prior-authorization requirement, or drop off the list, while the plan's name and premium stay the same. For 2027 the most a plan can charge as a drug deductible rises to $700, the yearly cap on what you pay for covered drugs rises to $2,400, and 15 more drugs get Medicare-negotiated prices on January 1.

AVOID IT: At Medicare.gov/plan-compare, enter every prescription and your pharmacy. It shows your estimated yearly drug cost for each plan, the one number your report cannot give you. Check that your pharmacy is still "preferred," not just "in network."

Medicare.gov, Part D costs; CMS, Medicare drug price negotiation, Nov 25, 2025.

Kwame Kuadey · The Benefits Insider™ · Adjunct Professor of Finance, Johns Hopkins Carey Business SchoolPage 1 of 2 · medicare.benefitsinsider.co

10 Medicare Mistakes to Avoid for 2027 · continued

The drug-plan trap, the Medigap door, and the call to hang up on

6

Mistake: Trusting the "average" drug-plan premium

The CMS subsidy that held stand-alone drug-plan premiums down ended December 31, 2026, a year early. CMS projects the average premium moving only from $35.09 to about $36. But the subsidy went to some plans and not others: AARP Medicare Rx Preferred rose $50 or more a month in all 50 states, over $75 in 37 of them. For the first time there are no $0-premium stand-alone drug plans unless you have Extra Help, and the average person has 9 to choose from, down from 11.

AVOID IT: Find the premium line in your Annual Notice of Change and compare it with the plans next door, not with the national average. Extra Help and the $2,400 cap are not affected by this.

CMS fact sheet, July 28, 2026; CMS press release, Sept 28, 2026; KFF, Oct 2, 2026.

7

Mistake: Picking another Advantage plan on reflex when yours is ending

When an Advantage plan leaves, you get a guaranteed right to buy a Medicare Supplement (Medigap) for 63 days after the plan ends, and you can apply up to 60 days before. The insurer cannot turn you down, charge you more for your health, or make you wait. Plans A, B, D, G, K or L from any insurer in your state, plus C or F if you were eligible for Medicare before 2020. The condition: the right exists only if you return to Original Medicare. Choose another Advantage plan and it is gone.

AVOID IT: If you have ever wanted out of Advantage but were told you would not pass health questions, this is the year to decide on purpose. Keep the non-renewal letter; the Supplement insurer will ask for it.

Medicare.gov, Medigap guaranteed issue rights.

8

Mistake: Choosing a plan for the extras, or assuming last year's extras are back

Dental allowances, over-the-counter cards, flex cards, grocery and utility benefits are reset by the plan every year, and a $0 premium can stay $0 while the allowance behind it shrinks. Some of the richest-sounding extras are Special Supplemental Benefits for the Chronically Ill: only members with a qualifying condition who meet the plan's criteria get them, and having the condition is not enough on its own. Some utility benefits can count as income for housing assistance.

AVOID IT: Find the one extra you actually used this year in the Annual Notice of Change and see what it is for 2027. Judge the plan on network, out-of-pocket maximum and drug coverage first. Extras are the tiebreaker, not the reason.

Plan Annual Notices of Change; CMS, Special Supplemental Benefits for the Chronically Ill.

9

Mistake: Assuming you make too much for help, and taking the first "no" on a claim

With full Extra Help, a benchmark drug plan costs $0 premium and $0 deductible, no more than $5.80 per generic and $14.40 per brand. The 2026 income limits are $23,940 single and $32,460 married, with 2027 limits due early in the year. A Medicare Savings Program can pay your Part B premium. A rule that would have made Savings Program enrollment automatic was blocked by the 2025 budget law, so you must apply for each program separately. And when a plan denies care: in 2024 only about 1 in 9 Advantage prior-authorization denials was appealed, and about 4 in 5 appeals won.

AVOID IT: Apply for Extra Help at ssa.gov/extrahelp and ask your state Medicaid office about a Medicare Savings Program, even if you think you are over the line. Appeal every denial; your plan's letter tells you how, and your State Health Insurance Assistance Program will help for free.

Medicare.gov, help with drug costs (fetched Nov 1, 2026); KFF analysis of CMS prior authorization data, 2024.

10

Mistake: Talking to the person who called you

Medicare does not call you to sell, verify or "update" anything, and no plan or agent is allowed to cold-call you about a Medicare plan. Open Enrollment is peak season for calls, texts and now cloned voices asking for your Medicare number, your bank details, or a "yes" on a recording. The one-time $90 Part B rebate paid in October needed no application, and anyone charging a fee to "claim" it was running a scam.

AVOID IT: If you did not start the call, hang up. Call the number on your Medicare card or your plan card instead: 1-800-MEDICARE, 24 hours a day. Give your Medicare number only to your doctor, your pharmacy, your plan, or someone you called. Report a scam at 1-800-MEDICARE.

Medicare.gov, reporting Medicare fraud; CMS, Part B premium rebate FAQ, Oct 3, 2026.

What to do this week

  1. Find your Annual Notice of Change. No letter? Call the number on your plan card and ask for it.
  2. Open your report. Every 2027 plan CMS approved for your county, out-of-pocket maximum first, at medicare.benefitsinsider.co.
  3. Two phone calls. Your doctor's office, then your plan: "Are you in network for this plan in 2027?"
  4. Your prescriptions. Medicare.gov/plan-compare with your drug list and pharmacy, for the real yearly cost.
  5. Decide by December 7. Enroll at Medicare.gov, by calling 1-800-MEDICARE, or with the plan directly. Nobody needs to call you.

Free, unbiased help from a human

Your State Health Insurance Assistance Program counsels for free and sells nothing. Medicare's own line is open 24 hours a day.

shiphelp.org · 1-877-839-2675
1-800-MEDICARE
Kwame Kuadey · The Benefits Insider™ · Author of The Social Security PlaybookPage 2 of 2 · medicare.benefitsinsider.co
Benefits Insider is not affiliated with, or endorsed by, the federal government, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, or the Social Security Administration. We do not sell insurance, and nothing here is an offer or a recommendation to buy any plan. This is general education, not individualized legal, tax, medical or financial advice. Plan counts and county exits are KFF's analysis of CMS data and may change as CMS revises its files; disenrollment-reason shares are NerdWallet's analysis of CMS surveys. Verified November 1, 2026. For all of your options: Medicare.gov, 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227, TTY 1-877-486-2048) or your State Health Insurance Assistance Program.